User:Josh/Tier List

Ranking Dynasties that I have experienced, as a player, Emperor, or observer

Tier	Tier Description	Dynasties
S	A good all-round interaction between mechanics, theme, and engaged and inventive play	Match Fixing Josh XXI Dead City Kevan XXXI Simulation Josh XX Banewood Mansion JonathanDark I Battlebots Josh XIX Demiurge Lendunistus I The Dark One Brendan VIII Art Broker Clucky VIII Giolitti Kevan XXVIII Venetian Election Josh XIV Unexplored Planet Kevan XXVII Visiting the Past Josh VI Hogwarts Brendan II Cold War Spies Kevan VII Werewolf Kevan V Elemental Wizards Cayvie I
A	A consistently fun dynasty to play, with a little room to improve in some fundamental aspects	Text Injection ais523 & Josh Photography 2 Josh XXII The Great Machine Lemon II Blizzard Habanero I Island Colony Trapdoorspyder III Atlantis Kevan XXX Road Trip Brendan IX Wrestling Metadynasty X Real Estate Trapdoorspyder I SCP Kevan XXVI Androids Kevan XIII Parliamentarians scshunt IV Nomic School Bucky V Ansible southpointingchariot I ClingBoom Bucky IV Stocks Purplebeard IV Steampunk ais523 II Murder Mansion Kevan VI Original Nomic Metadynasty V Movie Body Count Devenger I Kaiju Josh III Petri Dish Kevan IV Office Brendan I Hats Metadynasty I The Thing Kevan III Drafting ais523 X
B	Had interesting mechanics or inventive gameplay, but the experience stuttered or there was a core tension that was never resolved	Castle Defence JonathanDark IV Necromancy JonathanDark III Jenga Misty III Carnival Bucky VIII Party Trapdoorspyder II Elevator Kevan XXIX Vetos ais523 VII Vampires Josh XV AI lemon I Treaties Bucky VII Mosaic Clucky VII Versailles Josh XI Despot Josh VIII Heist Josh VII Band Cpt_Koen I Lifeboat Kevan IX Lego Josh V Nethack Darth Cliche II Mining Camp Purplebeard II Djinn Wakukee I Runes Bucky III Muffins Quazie I Galactic Damanor I Equity Josh XXIV Break-In Kevan XXXIII Anagrams JonathanDark VI
C	An interesting idea that never came together, or a good ruleset that didn't manifest as good play	Life Goals Ais523 IX Snail Racing Desertfrog I Hackers Zack II Royal Succession Vovix I Cities Metadynasty XI Diceless MadisonSilver I Parallel Universe Josh XVII Tic-Tac-Toe Misty II Boxes Zack I Censorship Josh XVI Also Boxes Misty I Mechs Josh XIII Spinning Wheels Metadynasty IX Animal Crossing Clucky VI Also Parallel Universe The Duke of Waltham I Cyberpunk Josh X Shipwreck RaichuKFM II Doomsday Cult Kevan XI Newspapers Kevan X Art Bateleur I Morninigton Crescent Kevan VIII Undefined Terms Ienpw III II Post-Apocalypse Darth Cliche I Einherjar Hix II Mob Josh I Great Flood Josh XII Food Trucks Kevan XXXIV
D	Dynasties that just didn't fire, for whatever reason	Chutes and Ladders Raven1207 I Monster Metropolis SingularByte I Atlantean Language Josh XVIII Amnesiac naught I Lab Rat Tantusar I Petty Crime ais523 VI Roman Gods Alecto I IQ ais523 IV April Fools Josh IV Board Games Josh II Container Ships Josh XXV