Difference between revisions of "History of victories"

From BlogNomic Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(add an Alliances tag)
(91 intermediate revisions by 10 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
 
This is an attempt to apply a taxonomy of different victory types to the history of BlogNomic. Those types are:-
 
This is an attempt to apply a taxonomy of different victory types to the history of BlogNomic. Those types are:-
 
+
[[file:Wintypes.png|right|500px]]
 
*<span style="color:#00af89">'''Conventional'''</span>: A player wins through regular dynastic-rule gameplay.
 
*<span style="color:#00af89">'''Conventional'''</span>: A player wins through regular dynastic-rule gameplay.
 
*<span style="color:#d33">'''Scam'''</span>: A player exploits the rules in an unexpected manner to achieve victory.
 
*<span style="color:#d33">'''Scam'''</span>: A player exploits the rules in an unexpected manner to achieve victory.
 
*<span style="color: #36c">'''Pooling'''</span>: Several players combine their resources to allow one of their number (often selected at random) to win.
 
*<span style="color: #36c">'''Pooling'''</span>: Several players combine their resources to allow one of their number (often selected at random) to win.
 +
*<span style="color:#888">'''Other'''</span>: The dynasty was ended in an unusual way (often early, through the decision of the group).
  
 
Conventional types:
 
Conventional types:
Line 25: Line 26:
 
* <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Meta]'''</span> No victor, the Dynasty results in a Metadynasty.
 
* <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Meta]'''</span> No victor, the Dynasty results in a Metadynasty.
  
Combination types (to be implemented below):
+
Combination types:
 
* X '''+''' Y: Combination of the two types (for example, a scam that relies on self-sacrificial action of several players in a cabal).
 
* X '''+''' Y: Combination of the two types (for example, a scam that relies on self-sacrificial action of several players in a cabal).
 
* X '''/''' Y: Presence of both types without them being part of the same manuvuer by the same victor/cabal, although each being instrumental to victory.
 
* X '''/''' Y: Presence of both types without them being part of the same manuvuer by the same victor/cabal, although each being instrumental to victory.
 
* X '''//''' Y: Presence of both types without them being performed by the same victor/cabal.
 
* X '''//''' Y: Presence of both types without them being performed by the same victor/cabal.
  
 +
Victory-relevant rules and actions:
 +
* <span style="color: #8e24ff>'''[No Comms]'''</span> No Private Communication rule was on, preventing private discussion among players
 +
* <span style="color: #8e24ff>'''[No Mantle]'''</span> No Mantle Passing rule existed as a non-default Building Block and was chosen to be active, preventing mantle passes
 +
* <span style="color: #8e24ff>'''[Alliances]'''</span> Declared Alliances was active, allowing mantle passes
 +
* <span style="color: #d9c525>'''[Traitor]'''</span> Traitor rule was on, Traitor used it to deny the pool at the end
 +
* <span style="color: #d9c525">'''[Mantle Roll]'''</span> A player won with assistance, on the agreement that they would then roll a weighted die and pass the mantle to an accomplice under certain outcomes
 +
 +
Other notes:
 +
* An "(undeclared)" victory is one where a player met the criteria for achieving victory, but did not (or was unable to) post a DoV
 +
 +
''Note: This table has been filled out by various players, with varying views on what qualifies as a particular type of victory, so may not be entirely representative or consistent.''
  
 
{| class="wikitable sortable"
 
{| class="wikitable sortable"
 
|-
 
|-
 
! Dynasty
 
! Dynasty
! Victor(s)
+
! style="width:20%" | Victor(s)
! Victory Method
+
! style="width:10%" | Victory Method
 
! Details
 
! Details
 
|-
 
|-
Line 41: Line 53:
 
| Kevan + Myke
 
| Kevan + Myke
 
| {{pooling}}
 
| {{pooling}}
| <span style="color: #15C715">'''[Resource]'''</span> Dynastic factor was pooled (Points)
+
| <span style="color: #15C715">'''[Resource]'''</span> Kevan gave Myke some Points, knowing this would end the round
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Myke]]
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Myke]]
Line 51: Line 63:
 
| Kevan + Myke
 
| Kevan + Myke
 
| {{pooling}}
 
| {{pooling}}
| <span style="color: #15C715">'''[Resource]'''</span> Dynastic factor was pooled (Gold)
+
| <span style="color: #15C715">'''[Resource]'''</span> Kevan gave Myke some Gold, knowing this would end the round
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Geran / The Second Dynasty of Myke|The Second Dynasty of Myke]]
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Geran / The Second Dynasty of Myke|The Second Dynasty of Myke]]
Line 65: Line 77:
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Anthony]]
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Anthony]]
 
| Est
 
| Est
| {{none}}
+
| {{other}}
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Election]'''</span> Players agreed to end the dynasty with a CfJ
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Election]'''</span> Players agreed to end the dynasty with a CfJ
 
|-
 
|-
Line 91: Line 103:
 
| Kevan + Josh + Keitalia + ChinDoGu?
 
| Kevan + Josh + Keitalia + ChinDoGu?
 
| {{pooling}} + <span style="color:#d33">Scam</span>
 
| {{pooling}} + <span style="color:#d33">Scam</span>
| <span style="color: #a2a9b1">'''[As Written]'''</span> <span style="color: #15C715">'''[Resource]'''</span> Pooling infinite Energy
+
| <span style="color: #a2a9b1">'''[As Written]'''</span> <span style="color: #15C715">'''[Resource]'''</span> A team pooled infinite Energy and were then able to choose a victor
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Joranj|The First Dynasty of Josh]]
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Joranj|The First Dynasty of Josh]]
Line 105: Line 117:
 
| [[The First Dynasty of SatyrEyes]]
 
| [[The First Dynasty of SatyrEyes]]
 
| None
 
| None
| {{none}}
+
| {{other}}
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Meta]'''</span>
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Meta]'''</span>
 
|-
 
|-
Line 116: Line 128:
 
| Brendan + Keitalia
 
| Brendan + Keitalia
 
| {{pooling}}
 
| {{pooling}}
| <span style="color: #C70000">'''[Action]'''</span>
+
| <span style="color: #C70000">'''[Action]'''</span> One player performed an action to make the other win
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Brendan]]
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Brendan]]
Line 175: Line 187:
 
| [[The Second Dynasty of Josh]]
 
| [[The Second Dynasty of Josh]]
 
| None
 
| None
| {{none}}
+
| {{other}}
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Meta]'''</span>
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Meta]'''</span>
 
|-
 
|-
Line 185: Line 197:
 
| [[The Second Dynasty of Chronos Phaenon]]
 
| [[The Second Dynasty of Chronos Phaenon]]
 
| Angry Grasshopper
 
| Angry Grasshopper
| {{none}}
+
| {{other}}
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Election]'''</span>
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Election]'''</span>
 
|-
 
|-
Line 200: Line 212:
 
| [[The First Dynasty of 75th Trombone]]
 
| [[The First Dynasty of 75th Trombone]]
 
| Elias IX
 
| Elias IX
| {{none}}
+
| {{other}}
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Merit Random]'''</span>
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Merit Random]'''</span>
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Elias IX]]
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Elias IX]]
 
| None  
 
| None  
| {{none}}
+
| {{other}}
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Meta]'''</span>
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Meta]'''</span>
 
|-
 
|-
Line 225: Line 237:
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Thelonious]]
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Thelonious]]
 
| Hix
 
| Hix
| {{none}}
+
| {{other}}
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Pure Random]'''</span>
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Pure Random]'''</span>
 
|-
 
|-
Line 245: Line 257:
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Doremi]]
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Doremi]]
 
| Chronos Phaenon
 
| Chronos Phaenon
| {{none}}
+
| {{other}}
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Election]'''</span>
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Election]'''</span>
 
|-
 
|-
Line 261: Line 273:
 
| Amnistar + Axeling  
 
| Amnistar + Axeling  
 
| {{pooling}} + <span style="color:#d33">Scam</span>
 
| {{pooling}} + <span style="color:#d33">Scam</span>
| <span style="color: #a2a9b1">'''[As Written]'''</span>
+
| <span style="color: #a2a9b1">'''[As Written]'''</span> Two players teamed up; the second player had "an idea e'd like to try" and was passed the mantle
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The Second Dynasty of Amnistar]]
 
| [[The Second Dynasty of Amnistar]]
Line 275: Line 287:
 
| [[The Third Dynasty of Clucky]]
 
| [[The Third Dynasty of Clucky]]
 
| Josh
 
| Josh
| {{none}}
+
| {{other}}
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Random]'''</span>
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Random]'''</span>
 
|-
 
|-
Line 305: Line 317:
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Purplebeard]]
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Purplebeard]]
 
| Rodlen
 
| Rodlen
| {{none}}
+
| {{other}}
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Election]'''</span>
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Election]'''</span>
 
|-
 
|-
Line 315: Line 327:
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Yoda]]
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Yoda]]
 
| Amnistar
 
| Amnistar
| {{none}}
+
| {{other}}
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Election]'''</span>
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Election]'''</span>
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The Third Dynasty of Amnistar]]
 
| [[The Third Dynasty of Amnistar]]
 
| Darknight
 
| Darknight
| {{none}}
+
| {{pooling}}
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Election]'''</span>? Proposal made to assign victory, after the Emperor idled.
+
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Election]'''</span> A proposal awarded victory early to a player with an almost insurmountable lead due to Endorsement pooling.
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Darknight]]
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Darknight]]
Line 335: Line 347:
 
| [[The Second Dynasty of Yoda]]
 
| [[The Second Dynasty of Yoda]]
 
| None
 
| None
| {{none}}
+
| {{other}}
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Meta]'''</span>
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Meta]'''</span>
 
|-
 
|-
Line 350: Line 362:
 
| [[The Fourth Dynasty of Amnistar]]
 
| [[The Fourth Dynasty of Amnistar]]
 
| Devenger
 
| Devenger
| {{none}}
+
| {{other}}
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Election]'''</span>  
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Election]'''</span>  
 
|-
 
|-
Line 365: Line 377:
 
| [[The First Dynasty of yuri_dragon_17|The First Dynasty of Ienpw III]]
 
| [[The First Dynasty of yuri_dragon_17|The First Dynasty of Ienpw III]]
 
| Qwazukee
 
| Qwazukee
| {{none}}
+
| {{other}}
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Election]'''</span>  
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Election]'''</span>  
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Qwazukee]]
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Qwazukee]]
 
| Klisz
 
| Klisz
| {{none}}
+
| {{other}}
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Election]'''</span>
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Election]'''</span>
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Darth Cliche|The First Dynasty of Klisz]]
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Darth Cliche|The First Dynasty of Klisz]]
 
| None
 
| None
| {{none}}
+
| {{other}}
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Meta]'''</span>
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Meta]'''</span>
 
|-
 
|-
Line 384: Line 396:
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The Third Dynasty of Bucky]]
 
| [[The Third Dynasty of Bucky]]
| ais523 + Wakukee  
+
| ais523 + Wakukee + Klisz
 
| {{scam}} + <span style="color:#33d">Pooling</span>
 
| {{scam}} + <span style="color:#33d">Pooling</span>
| <span style="color: #a2a9b1">'''[As Written]'''</span> Collaborative scam.
+
| <span style="color: #a2a9b1">'''[As Written]'''</span> Collaborative scam to cast a "target player achieves victory" spell
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Wakukee]]
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Wakukee]]
Line 396: Line 408:
 
| ais523 + Flurie + Hellzapoppin + Klisz
 
| ais523 + Flurie + Hellzapoppin + Klisz
 
| {{pooling}}
 
| {{pooling}}
|  
+
| <span style="color: #C70000">'''[Action]'''</span> To win, you needed to guess some information (and could only try once); the pool pooled their information, then used their numbers to make multiple guesses.
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The Second Dynasty of ais523]]
 
| [[The Second Dynasty of ais523]]
Line 416: Line 428:
 
| Ienpw III  
 
| Ienpw III  
 
| {{conventional}}
 
| {{conventional}}
|  
+
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Election]'''</span> themed dynasty
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The Second Dynasty of Ienpw III]]
 
| [[The Second Dynasty of Ienpw III]]
 
| Klisz
 
| Klisz
| {{none}}
+
| {{other}}
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Election]'''</span>
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Election]'''</span>
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The Second Dynasty of Darth Cliche|The Second Dynasty of Klisz]]
 
| [[The Second Dynasty of Darth Cliche|The Second Dynasty of Klisz]]
 
| Galdyn + Ienpw III
 
| Galdyn + Ienpw III
| {{pooling}}  
+
| {{pooling}}
 
|  
 
|  
 
|-
 
|-
Line 451: Line 463:
 
| Alecto + Josh + Kevan
 
| Alecto + Josh + Kevan
 
| {{scam}} + <span style="color:#33d">Pooling</span>
 
| {{scam}} + <span style="color:#33d">Pooling</span>
| <span style="color: #a2a9b1">'''[As Written]'''</span> <span style="color: #15C715">'''[Resource]'''</span> Read-as-written, Dynasty factor pooled. Collaborative scam.
+
| <span style="color: #a2a9b1">'''[As Written]'''</span> With a "last zombie standing wins" rule, the game's three zombies agreed to roll a die to decide which two would voluntarily idle.
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Alecto]]
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Alecto]]
Line 490: Line 502:
 
| [[The Third Dynasty of Yoda]]
 
| [[The Third Dynasty of Yoda]]
 
| Bucky
 
| Bucky
| {{none}}
+
| {{other}}
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Election]'''</span>
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Election]'''</span>
 
|-
 
|-
Line 505: Line 517:
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Bateleur]]
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Bateleur]]
 
| None
 
| None
| {{none}}
+
| {{other}}
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Meta]'''</span>
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Meta]'''</span>
 
|-
 
|-
Line 525: Line 537:
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Cpt_Koen]]
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Cpt_Koen]]
 
| Clucky
 
| Clucky
| {{none}}
+
| {{other}}
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Merit Random]'''</span>
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Merit Random]'''</span>
 
|-
 
|-
Line 551: Line 563:
 
| Bucky + Quirck
 
| Bucky + Quirck
 
| {{pooling}}
 
| {{pooling}}
|  
+
| Bucky "bribed" Quirck (it is unclear with what) to idle out and trigger their own victory
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The Fifth Dynasty of Bucky]]
 
| [[The Fifth Dynasty of Bucky]]
Line 590: Line 602:
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Skju]]
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Skju]]
 
| None
 
| None
| {{none}}
+
| {{other}}
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Meta]'''</span> Metadynasty started by proposal.
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Meta]'''</span> Metadynasty started by proposal.
 
|-
 
|-
Line 600: Line 612:
 
| [[The Fifth Dynasty of Purplebeard]]
 
| [[The Fifth Dynasty of Purplebeard]]
 
| Spitemaster
 
| Spitemaster
| {{none}}
+
| {{other}}
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Merit Random]'''</span>
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Merit Random]'''</span>
 
|-
 
|-
Line 611: Line 623:
 
| Clucky + RaichuKFM  
 
| Clucky + RaichuKFM  
 
| {{scam}} + <span style="color:#33d">Pooling</span>
 
| {{scam}} + <span style="color:#33d">Pooling</span>
| <span style="color: #a2a9b1">'''[As Written]'''</span> <span style="color: #ac6600">'''[Bloc Vote]'''</span>
+
| <span style="color: #a2a9b1">'''[As Written]'''</span> <span style="color: #ac6600">'''[Altered Bloc Vote]'''</span> Two players created a scammed UN resolution which would flip a coin and assign one of them victory
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The Second Dynasty of RaichuKFM]]
 
| [[The Second Dynasty of RaichuKFM]]
 
| ''The Alien''
 
| ''The Alien''
| {{none}}
+
| {{other}}
 
| An NPC achieved victory
 
| An NPC achieved victory
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The First Dynasty of The Alien]]
 
| [[The First Dynasty of The Alien]]
 
| Benzene + Kevan
 
| Benzene + Kevan
| {{pooling}}
+
| {{pooling}}  
|  
+
| Kevan proposed a new chamber which would assign victory at weighted random to its inhabitants, which were limited to Kevan and (it seems?) Benzene
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Benzene]]
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Benzene]]
 
| IceFromHell + RaichuKFM
 
| IceFromHell + RaichuKFM
| {{pooling}}
+
| {{pooling}}  
|  
+
| A stalemate was resolved with a proposal to toss a coin for victory
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The Third Dynasty of RaichuKFM]]
 
| [[The Third Dynasty of RaichuKFM]]
Line 635: Line 647:
 
| [[The Sixth Dynasty of Purplebeard]]
 
| [[The Sixth Dynasty of Purplebeard]]
 
| Kevan
 
| Kevan
| {{conventional}} + None
+
| {{conventional}} + Other
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Election]'''</span> Players agreed to end the dynasty early, with one player in a clear lead.
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Election]'''</span> Players agreed to end the dynasty early, with one player in a clear lead.
 
|-
 
|-
Line 661: Line 673:
 
| Brendan + Kevan + Mideg
 
| Brendan + Kevan + Mideg
 
| {{pooling}}
 
| {{pooling}}
| <span style="color: #C70000">'''[Action]'''</span> <span style="color: #15C715">'''[Resource]'''</span> Actions and "Standing" were pooled
+
| <span style="color: #C70000">'''[Action]'''</span> <span style="color: #15C715">'''[Resource]'''</span> <span style="color: #d9c525">'''[Mantle Roll]'''</span> Actions and "Standing" were pooled
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Mideg]]
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Mideg]]
 
| Kevan
 
| Kevan
| {{conventional}} + None
+
| {{conventional}} + Other
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Merit Random]'''</span> A sudden death die roll was proposed based on scores so far.
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Merit Random]'''</span> A sudden death die roll was proposed based on scores so far.
 
|-
 
|-
Line 695: Line 707:
 
| [[The Sixteenth Dynasty of Kevan]]
 
| [[The Sixteenth Dynasty of Kevan]]
 
| Ais523 + Thrawn
 
| Ais523 + Thrawn
| {{conventional}} + <span style="color:#33d">Pooling</span>
+
| {{conventional}} + <span style="color:#33d">Pooling</span> Midgame agreement to pass the mantle if assisted
 
|  
 
|  
 
|-
 
|-
Line 715: Line 727:
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Moonroof ]]
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Moonroof ]]
 
| RaichuKFM
 
| RaichuKFM
| {{conventional}}
+
| {{Conventional}} + <span style="color:#d33">Scam</span>
|  
+
| Dynastic voting mechanics enabled an unstoppable scam proposal.
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The Fourth Dynasty of RaichuKFM]]
 
| [[The Fourth Dynasty of RaichuKFM]]
Line 724: Line 736:
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The Second Dynasty of Larrytheturtle]]
 
| [[The Second Dynasty of Larrytheturtle]]
| Brendan + Kevan
+
| Brendan (declared) + Kevan (undeclared)
 
| {{pooling}} + <span style="color:#d33">Scam</span>
 
| {{pooling}} + <span style="color:#d33">Scam</span>
| Collaborative scam
+
| Collaborative scam to earn Kevan a "win the game" item, where after a coin flip he declined to declare victory and passed it to Brendan
 
|-  
 
|-  
 
| [[The Fifth Dynasty of Brendan]]
 
| [[The Fifth Dynasty of Brendan]]
Line 739: Line 751:
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The Sixth Dynasty of Brendan]]
 
| [[The Sixth Dynasty of Brendan]]
|
+
| RaichuKFM
| {{unknown}}
+
| {{other}}
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Merit Random]'''</span> There seems to have been some chaos at the end, where two players relied on Brendan posting something, and they ended up proposing that one of those two would win (unclear how those two players reached such a position where one of the two would be the winner, though)
+
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Merit Random]'''</span> The front-runners were forced into a coinflip (seemingly against one of their wishes) after endgame looked to be down to the timing of a future Imperial action.
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The Fifth Dynasty of RaichuKFM ]]
 
| [[The Fifth Dynasty of RaichuKFM ]]
Line 776: Line 788:
 
| Cuddlebeam + Pokes
 
| Cuddlebeam + Pokes
 
| {{pooling}}
 
| {{pooling}}
| <span style="color: #15C715">'''[Resource]'''</span> Dynastic Factor was pooled (Artifacts)
+
| <span style="color: #15C715">'''[Resource]'''</span> Players flipped a coin to decide who to pool game-winning Artefacts to
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Cuddlebeam]]
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Cuddlebeam]]
Line 786: Line 798:
 
| Card + Cuddlebeam + Derrick + Sesquipedalian  
 
| Card + Cuddlebeam + Derrick + Sesquipedalian  
 
| {{pooling}}
 
| {{pooling}}
| <span style="color: #ac6600">'''[Altered Bloc Vote]'''</span> Votes were pooled (voting power differed between players due to a dynastic mechanic)
+
| <span style="color: #ac6600">'''[Altered Bloc Vote]'''</span> Pooling team pushed through a "random team member wins" proposal (voting power differed between players due to a dynastic mechanic)
 
|-  
 
|-  
 
| [[The Second Dynasty of Cuddlebeam]]
 
| [[The Second Dynasty of Cuddlebeam]]
 
| None  
 
| None  
| {{none}}
+
| {{other}}
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Meta]'''</span>
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Meta]'''</span>
 
|-
 
|-
Line 815: Line 827:
 
| [[The First Coregency of Diabecko and card]]
 
| [[The First Coregency of Diabecko and card]]
 
| Kevan
 
| Kevan
| {{none}}
+
| {{other}}
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Election]'''</span>
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Election]'''</span>
 
|-
 
|-
Line 831: Line 843:
 
| Cuddlebeam + Derrick + Kevan + Pokes + 9SpaceKing
 
| Cuddlebeam + Derrick + Kevan + Pokes + 9SpaceKing
 
| {{pooling}}  
 
| {{pooling}}  
| <span style="color: #ac6600">'''[Bloc Vote]'''</span> Votes were pooled
+
| <span style="color: #ac6600">'''[Bloc Vote]'''</span> A CfJ was raised to assign victory to a random early supporter of that CfJ
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The Third Dynasty of Cuddlebeam]]
 
| [[The Third Dynasty of Cuddlebeam]]
 
| card
 
| card
| {{none}}
+
| {{other}}
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Pure Random]'''</span>
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Pure Random]'''</span>
 
|-
 
|-
Line 876: Line 888:
 
| Ienpw III + Kevan + TyGuy6
 
| Ienpw III + Kevan + TyGuy6
 
| {{pooling}}
 
| {{pooling}}
| <span style="color: #15C715">'''[Resource]'''</span> Dynastic factor was pooled (Food)
+
| <span style="color: #15C715">'''[Resource]'''</span> Dynastic factor was pooled (Food). Some suggestion that mantle rolling was discussed, but not used by the team who won.
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Farsight]]
 
| [[The First Dynasty of Farsight]]
 
| Thunder + TyGuy6
 
| Thunder + TyGuy6
 
| {{pooling}}
 
| {{pooling}}
| <span style="color: #C70000">'''[Action]'''</span>
+
| <span style="color: #C70000">'''[Action]'''</span> <span style="color: #d9c525">'''[Mantle Roll]'''</span> Thunder agreed to act as an inert target for TyGuy's attacks, to help them score Treasure.
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The First Dynasty of TyGuy6]]
 
| [[The First Dynasty of TyGuy6]]
 
| Kevan + Pokes
 
| Kevan + Pokes
 
| {{pooling}}
 
| {{pooling}}
| <span style="color: #C70000">'''[Action]'''</span>
+
| <span style="color: #C70000">'''[Action]'''</span> <span style="color: #d9c525">'''[Mantle Roll]'''</span> Kevan and Pokes were virtually tied on a slow route to victory, and agreed to trigger the endgame early and mantle roll from whatever the outcome was, rather than play it out and possibly be sniped by other players.
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The Fourth Dynasty of pokes]]
 
| [[The Fourth Dynasty of pokes]]
 
| Cuddlebeam + TyGuy6
 
| Cuddlebeam + TyGuy6
 
| {{pooling}}
 
| {{pooling}}
| <span style="color: #C70000">'''[Action]'''</span>
+
| <span style="color: #C70000">'''[Action]'''</span> <span style="color: #d9c525">'''[Mantle Roll]'''</span> With only three active players, Cuddlebeam proposed that they win the game, with TyGuy6 supporting in exchange for a 50% mantle roll.
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The Fourth Dynasty of Cuddlebeam]]
 
| [[The Fourth Dynasty of Cuddlebeam]]
Line 900: Line 912:
 
| [[The Second Dynasty of TyGuy6]]
 
| [[The Second Dynasty of TyGuy6]]
 
| Cuddlebeam
 
| Cuddlebeam
| {{none}}
+
| {{other}}
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Pure Random]'''</span>
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Pure Random]'''</span>
 
|-
 
|-
Line 906: Line 918:
 
| Card + Cuddlebeam + Darknight + The Duke of Waltham
 
| Card + Cuddlebeam + Darknight + The Duke of Waltham
 
| {{pooling}} + <span style="color:#d33">Scam</span>
 
| {{pooling}} + <span style="color:#d33">Scam</span>
| <span style="color: #C70000">'''[Action]'''</span> <span style="color: #15C715">'''[Resource]'''</span> <span style="color: #a2a9b1">'''[As Written]'''</span> Various different maneuvers performed for the benefit of a single player's victory condition.
+
| <span style="color: #C70000">'''[Action]'''</span> <span style="color: #15C715">'''[Resource]'''</span> <span style="color: #a2a9b1">'''[As Written]'''</span> <span style="color: #d9c525">'''[Mantle Roll]'''</span> Various different maneuvers performed for the benefit of a single player's victory condition.
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The First Dynasty of The Duke of Waltham]]
 
| [[The First Dynasty of The Duke of Waltham]]
Line 916: Line 928:
 
| Clucky + Naught
 
| Clucky + Naught
 
| {{pooling}}
 
| {{pooling}}
| <span style="color: #C70000">'''[Action]'''</span>
+
| <span style="color: #C70000">'''[Action]'''</span> Naught lowered their score to allow Clucky to win
 +
|-
 +
| [[The Sixth Dynasty of Clucky]]
 +
| Naught
 +
| {{other}}
 +
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Merit Random]'''</span>
 +
|-
 +
| [[The First Dynasty of naught]]
 +
| none
 +
| {{other}}
 +
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Meta]'''</span>
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The Ninth Metadynasty]]
 
| [[The Ninth Metadynasty]]
 
| Kevan
 
| Kevan
| {{none}}
+
| {{other}}
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Merit Random]'''</span>
 
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Merit Random]'''</span>
 
|-
 
|-
Line 926: Line 948:
 
| Josh + Cuddlebeam
 
| Josh + Cuddlebeam
 
| {{pooling}}
 
| {{pooling}}
| <span style="color: #C70000">'''[Action]'''</span>
+
| <span style="color: #C70000">'''[Action]'''</span> <span style="color: #d9c525">'''[Mantle Roll]'''</span> Cuddlebeam followed instructions for 40% of mantle
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The Twelfth Dynasty of Josh]]
 
| [[The Twelfth Dynasty of Josh]]
Line 944: Line 966:
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The Seventh Dynasty of Bucky]]
 
| [[The Seventh Dynasty of Bucky]]
| Brendan + Josh + Jumble
+
| Brendan + Josh + Clucky (declared and enacted) // Kevan (declared) // Raven1207 (undeclared)
 
| {{pooling}}
 
| {{pooling}}
| <span style="color: #C70000">'''[Action]'''</span> Action pooled was letter changes.
+
| <span style="color:#0089af">'''[Bloc Vote]'''</span> <span style="color: #d9c525">'''[Mantle Roll]'''</span> A scam unintentionally gave multiple players victory; four of those players sold mantle roll offers in exchange for votes supporting their preferred DoV
 
|-
 
|-
 
| [[The Fourteenth Dynasty of Josh]]
 
| [[The Fourteenth Dynasty of Josh]]
Line 955: Line 977:
 
| Josh + Brendan + Lemonfanta + Pokes + Jumble + Darknight
 
| Josh + Brendan + Lemonfanta + Pokes + Jumble + Darknight
 
| {{pooling}}
 
| {{pooling}}
| <span style="color: #15C715">'''[Resource]'''</span> <span style="color: #C70000">'''[Action]'''</span> Players pooled Pegs and resigned subgames to assist a single player.
+
| <span style="color: #15C715">'''[Resource]'''</span> <span style="color: #C70000">'''[Action]'''</span> <span style="color: #d9c525">'''[Mantle Roll]'''</span> Players pooled Pegs and resigned subgames to assist a single player. This was partly under the tracked Favours rule but also included a mantle roll.
 +
|-
 +
| [[The First Dynasty of lemonfanta]]
 +
| Clucky + Kevan
 +
| {{pooling}}
 +
| <span style="color: #C70000">'''[Action]'''</span> <span style="color: #d9c525">'''[Mantle Roll]'''</span> <span style="color: #d9c525">'''[Traitor]'''</span> An agreed mantle roll plan was declined by the Traitor.
 +
|-
 +
| [[The Eighth Dynasty of Clucky]]
 +
| Josh
 +
| {{conventional}}
 +
| <span style="color: #8e24ff">'''[No Comms]'''</span>
 +
|-
 +
| [[The Fifteenth Dynasty of Josh]]
 +
| Jumble
 +
| {{other}}
 +
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Merit Random]'''</span> Merit based on Blood Mana Crystals.
 +
|-
 +
| [[The First Dynasty of Jumble]]
 +
| ais523
 +
| {{scam}}
 +
| <span style="color: #a2a9b1">'''[As Written]'''</span> Borderline case: A series of normal moves were strung together into a over 6,000 move update, immediately achieving victory.
 +
|-
 +
| [[The Seventh Dynasty of ais523]]
 +
| Josh + Trapdoorspyder + Cuddlebeam
 +
| {{conventional}} + <span style="color:#33d">Pooling</span>
 +
| <span style="color: #C70000">'''[Action]'''</span> <span style="color: #d9c525">'''[Mantle Roll]'''</span> Josh enacted a series of proposals which would work together to grant him victory, and brought some votes from Trapdoorspyder and Cuddlebeam to ensure that the queue stayed locked
 +
|-
 +
| [[The Sixteenth Dynasty of Josh]]
 +
| Kevan + Clucky
 +
| {{conventional}} + <span style="color:#33d">Pooling</span>
 +
| <span style="color: #15C715">'''[Resource]'''</span> <span style="color: #d9c525">'''[Mantle Roll]'''</span> <span style="color: #8e24ff">'''[No Comms]'''</span> Clucky donated some Citizens to a critical Building, but later retracted a mantle roll agreement due to some (limited ruleset-permitted backchannel) miscommunication around possible scams that didn't actually work.
 +
|-
 +
| [[The Twenty-Ninth Dynasty of Kevan]]
 +
| Trapdoorspyder + Cuddlebeam + TyGuy6 + redtara
 +
| {{other}} + <span style="color:#33d">Pooling</span> + <span style="color:#d33">Scam</span>
 +
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Election]'''</span><span style="color: #15C715">'''[Resource]'''</span> <span style="color: #d9c525">'''[Mantle Roll]'''</span> A cabal of players achieved enough of a poolable resource that would allow them to win (partially scam-gained). This was used as merit to achieve a winning CFJ, due to unconventional circumstances concerning the Emperor.
 +
|-
 +
| colspan=4 style="text-align:center; background:#fff; font-size:0.8em; font-style:italic; padding:0.5em" | 23 October 2021: Players vote in a dynastic rule of [https://blognomic.com/archive/a_simple_solution "the mantle may not be passed"] during the next dynasty; it is kept in place for the one after it, and then [https://blognomic.com/archive/a_note_for_players_who_are_not_privy_to_recent_discord_discussions made into] a default-off Special Case rule
 +
|-
 +
| [[The First Dynasty of Trapdoorspyder]]
 +
| None
 +
| {{none}}
 +
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Meta]'''</span> <span style="color: #8e24ff>'''[No Mantle]'''</span> An enacted Merit Random resolution contained a scam that was voted down, and could not otherwise be processed. Players then voted to play a metadynasty which only two of the possible merit-random winners of this dynasty could win.
 +
|-
 +
| [[The Tenth Metadynasty]]
 +
| Brendan
 +
| {{pooling}}
 +
| <span style="color:#0089af">'''[Bloc Vote]'''</span> <span style="color: #8e24ff>'''[No Mantle]'''</span>: Played as a tiebreaker dynasty between two not-quite-quorate teams, a defector supported Brendan's victory proposal.
 +
|-
 +
| [[The Eighth Dynasty of Brendan]]
 +
| Brendan + Kevan
 +
| {{pooling}}
 +
| <span style="color: #15C715">'''[Resource]'''</span> <span style="color: #d9c525">'''[Mantle Roll]'''</span> <span style="color: #8e24ff">'''[No Comms]'''</span> <span style="color: #8e24ff>'''[No Mantle]'''</span> <span style="color: #8e24ff>'''[Alliances]'''</span> Information was shared (the Dark One's weakness) to coin flip on one of those players winning. No Mantle and No Comms were in effect but didn't apply to the Malign Emperor.
 +
|-
 +
| [[The Ninth Dynasty of Brendan]]
 +
| Clucky + TyGuy6 + Zack
 +
| {{pooling}}
 +
| <span style="color: #15C715">'''[Resource]'''</span> <span style="color: #8e24ff>'''[No Mantle]'''</span> <span style="color: #8e24ff>'''[Alliances]'''</span> Players pooled freely-tradeable coins to hit the victory condition (Josh and Jumble had also donated coins to the ultimate winner, but not with the intention of a victory split).
 +
|-
 +
| [[The First Dynasty of Zack]]
 +
| Jumble
 +
| {{other}}
 +
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Merit Random]'''</span> An unexpected interaction of several rules allowed anyone to claim free winshare for the end-of-game roll-off.
 +
|-
 +
| [[The Second Dynasty of Jumble]]
 +
| Brendan + Josh + ?
 +
| {{scam}}
 +
| <span style="color: #a2a9b1">'''[As Written]'''</span> <span style="color: #d9c525">'''[Mantle Roll]'''</span> Brendan won via exploiting a mechanic that allowed him to take any action, then passed it to Josh in an undisclosed victory split.
 +
|-
 +
| [[The Seventeenth Dynasty of Josh]]
 +
| MadisonSilver
 +
| {{scam}}
 +
| <span style="color: #a2a9b1">'''[As Written]'''</span> <span style="color: #8e24ff>'''[No Mantle]'''</span> <span style="color: #8e24ff>'''[Alliances]'''</span> Some kind of manipulation of the GPT text generator that the dynasty was using.
 +
|-
 +
| [[The First Dynasty of MadisonSilver]]
 +
| Josh
 +
| {{other}}
 +
| A DoV which turned out not to be based on successfully Achieving Victory was enacted anyway.
 +
|-
 +
| [[The Eighteenth Dynasty of Josh]]
 +
| Kevan
 +
| {{other}}
 +
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Election]'''</span> <span style="color: #8e24ff>'''[No Mantle]'''</span> After the ruleset was suspended due to a lack of activity, a theme-election mechanic was proposed; Kevan won as the only participant
 +
|-
 +
| [[The Thirtieth Dynasty of Kevan]]
 +
| Lendunistus + Josh + SupernovaStarbright
 +
| {{scam}} + <span style="color:#33d">Pooling</span>
 +
| <span style="color: #a2a9b1">'''[As Written]'''</span> <span style="color: #d9c525">'''[Mantle Roll]'''</span> The group supported each others' changes to allow a scam to be completed
 +
|-
 +
| [[The First Dynasty of lendunistus]]
 +
| Josh + Kevan + Trapdoorspyder
 +
| {{scam}} + <span style="color:#33d">Pooling</span>
 +
| <span style="color: #a2a9b1">'''[As Written]'''</span> <span style="color: #d9c525">'''[Mantle Roll]'''</span> Josh proposed a scam, two other players spotted it (?) but accepted a share of mantle roll in exchange for keeping quiet about it.
 +
|-
 +
| [[The Nineteenth Dynasty of Josh]]
 +
| SingularByte
 +
| {{conventional}}
 +
| <span style="color: #8e24ff>'''[No Mantle]'''</span>
 +
|-
 +
| colspan=4 style="text-align:center; background:#fff; font-size:0.8em; font-style:italic; padding:0.5em" | 1 September 2022: [https://blognomic.com/archive/there_can_be_only_one_special_case Mantle passing is now off by default]
 +
|-
 +
| [[The First Dynasty of SingularByte]]
 +
| Trapdoorspyder
 +
| {{other}}
 +
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Merit Random]'''</span>
 +
|-
 +
| [[The Second Dynasty of Trapdoorspyder]]
 +
| Bucky
 +
| {{scam}}
 +
| <span style="color: #a2a9b1">'''[As Written]'''</span>
 +
|-
 +
| [[The Eighth Dynasty of Bucky]]
 +
| JonathanDark
 +
| {{conventional}}
 +
|-
 +
| [[The First Dynasty of JonathanDark]]
 +
| Trapdoorspyder
 +
| {{pooling}}
 +
| <span style="color: #C70000">'''[Action]'''</span> SingularByte voluntarily agreed to assist and kingmake Trapdoorspyder using the power of Katastrophe, not wanting to be Emperor themselves
 +
|-
 +
| [[The Third Dynasty of Trapdoorspyder]]
 +
| Chiiika + Habanero
 +
| {{pooling}}
 +
| <span style="color: #15C715">'''[Resource]'''</span> <span style="color: #d9c525">'''[Mantle Roll]'''</span> <span style="color: #8e24ff>'''[Alliances]'''</span> Players pooled farmable Resources and combined the outputs of resource-producing Buildings to allow Chiiika to build the 4 Buildings necessary to win. Chiiika passed the Mantle to Habanero under the Alliances rule
 +
|-
 +
| [[The First Dynasty of Habanero]]
 +
| JonathanDark
 +
| {{scam}}
 +
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Merit Random]'''</span> Brendan successfully exploited an infinite resource scam; however, since there was no victory condition in the ruleset, an endgame rolloff was proposed. JonathanDark won the roll.
 +
|-
 +
| [[The Second Dynasty of JonathanDark]]
 +
| Misty
 +
| {{conventional}}
 +
| <span style="color: #8e24ff">'''[No Comms]'''</span>
 +
|-
 +
| [[The Third Dynasty of Misty]]
 +
| none
 +
| {{other}}
 +
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Meta]'''</span>
 +
|-
 +
| [[The Eleventh Metadynasty]]
 +
| Josh
 +
| {{other}}
 +
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Merit Random]'''</span> When a game action caused the outcome of the Merit Random roll to become ambiguous (either Josh or Redtara had won it and consensus was split), Redtara stood down and proposed that Josh had won it.
 +
|-
 +
| [[The Twentieth Dynasty of Josh]]
 +
| Lemon
 +
| {{conventional}}
 +
| <span style="color: #8e24ff">'''[No Comms]'''</span>
 +
|-
 +
| [[The Second Dynasty of lemon]]
 +
| Kevan + lendunistus
 +
| {{pooling}}
 +
| <span style="color: #C70000">'''[Action]'''</span> <span style="color: #d9c525">'''[Mantle Roll]'''</span> <span style="color: #8e24ff">'''[No Comms]'''</span> <span style="color: #8e24ff>'''[Alliances]'''</span> Kevan performed some game actions for a 35% split of the mantle, under the Alliances rule.
 +
|-
 +
| [[The Thirty-First Dynasty of Kevan]]
 +
| Josh
 +
| {{conventional}}
 +
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Merit Random]'''</span> With a clear conventional lead, Josh proposed that the dynasty should end immediately with him 100% winning.
 +
|-
 +
| [[The Twenty-First Dynasty of Josh]]
 +
| Clucky
 +
| {{conventional}}
 +
|
 +
|-
 +
| [[The Ninth Dynasty of Clucky]]
 +
| Vovix + Snisbo
 +
| {{pooling}}
 +
| <span style="color: #C70000">'''[Action]'''</span> Snisbo agreed to cast a spell that would give victory to Vovix (with no chance of mantle pass) "in exchange for a general IOU"
 +
|-
 +
| [[The First Dynasty of Vovix]]
 +
| JonathanDark + Josh + Clucky
 +
| {{pooling}}
 +
| <span style="color: #C70000">'''[Action]'''</span> Clucky (being in with a chance of victory) and Josh (repaying a favour from an earlier dynasty) helped to kill the King.
 +
|-
 +
| [[The Third Dynasty of JonathanDark]]
 +
| Zack
 +
| {{conventional}}
 +
|
 +
|-
 +
| [[The Second Dynasty of Zack]]
 +
| JonathanDark
 +
| {{other}}
 +
| <span style="color:white; background:#a2a9b1">'''[Merit Random]'''</span>
 +
|-
 
|}
 
|}

Revision as of 18:27, 29 February 2024

This is an attempt to apply a taxonomy of different victory types to the history of BlogNomic. Those types are:-

Wintypes.png
  • Conventional: A player wins through regular dynastic-rule gameplay.
  • Scam: A player exploits the rules in an unexpected manner to achieve victory.
  • Pooling: Several players combine their resources to allow one of their number (often selected at random) to win.
  • Other: The dynasty was ended in an unusual way (often early, through the decision of the group).

Conventional types:

  • [Assisted]: Assisted conventional. Win that relies on an alliance/collaboration but there is no Pooling maneuver, for example, a trade of resources or synergy without deliberate/planned self-sacrifice.

Scam types:

  • [As Written] Read-as-written (RAW). A rule or rules being exploited in a surprising but uncontested manner.
  • [Late] Late reveal. A player delaying informing others that a rule may have been broken, to gain advantage.
  • [Admin] Admin advantage. A scam which could only be performed by an admin player.

Pooling types:

  • [Resource] Pooling a tradeable game resource
  • [Action] One or more players taking an action to give another victory
  • [Bloc Vote] Block-voting as a group, in order to assign victory among that group
  • [Altered Bloc Vote] Same as above, but voting mechanics are altered by some dynastic rule.

Other Dynasty end types:

  • [Election] Election: a victor is elected by the players (typically for dynastic merit or popularity), either through an election among several players, or by passing a vote to crown one specific winner.
  • [Pure Random] A random player chosen among an impartial set of players is the victor.
  • [Merit Random] Random, but the victor is a set of players chosen by their merit in the game (for example, two tied players in the lead)
  • [Meta] No victor, the Dynasty results in a Metadynasty.

Combination types:

  • X + Y: Combination of the two types (for example, a scam that relies on self-sacrificial action of several players in a cabal).
  • X / Y: Presence of both types without them being part of the same manuvuer by the same victor/cabal, although each being instrumental to victory.
  • X // Y: Presence of both types without them being performed by the same victor/cabal.

Victory-relevant rules and actions:

  • [No Comms] No Private Communication rule was on, preventing private discussion among players
  • [No Mantle] No Mantle Passing rule existed as a non-default Building Block and was chosen to be active, preventing mantle passes
  • [Alliances] Declared Alliances was active, allowing mantle passes
  • [Traitor] Traitor rule was on, Traitor used it to deny the pool at the end
  • [Mantle Roll] A player won with assistance, on the agreement that they would then roll a weighted die and pass the mantle to an accomplice under certain outcomes

Other notes:

  • An "(undeclared)" victory is one where a player met the criteria for achieving victory, but did not (or was unable to) post a DoV

Note: This table has been filled out by various players, with varying views on what qualifies as a particular type of victory, so may not be entirely representative or consistent.

Dynasty Victor(s) Victory Method Details
Round One Kevan + Myke Pooling [Resource] Kevan gave Myke some Points, knowing this would end the round
The First Dynasty of Myke Lyndse Conventional
The First Dynasty of Lyndse Kevan + Myke Pooling [Resource] Kevan gave Myke some Gold, knowing this would end the round
The Second Dynasty of Myke Kevan Scam [As Written] Read-as-written.
The First Dynasty of Kevan Anthony Conventional
The First Dynasty of Anthony Est Other [Election] Players agreed to end the dynasty with a CfJ
The First Dynasty of est Kevan Scam [As Written]
The Second Dynasty of Kevan Damanor Conventional
The First Dynasty of Damanor Kevan Scam [As Written]
The Third Dynasty of Kevan Cayvie Scam [As Written]
The First Dynasty of Cayvie Kevan + Josh + Keitalia + ChinDoGu? Pooling + Scam [As Written] [Resource] A team pooled infinite Energy and were then able to choose a victor
The First Dynasty of Josh Keitalia Conventional or Pooling The victor relied on a tradeable commodity, but history does not relate whether any was donated from other players
The First Dynasty of Keitalia SatyrEyes Conventional
The First Dynasty of SatyrEyes None Other [Meta]
The First Metadynasty Cayvie Scam [As Written] (May have had an accomplice if it got a second vote?)
The Second Dynasty of Cayvie Brendan + Keitalia Pooling [Action] One player performed an action to make the other win
The First Dynasty of Brendan Kevan Conventional
The Fourth Dynasty of Kevan Knightking Conventional
The First Dynasty of Knightking Chronos Phaenon Conventional Team-based game
The First Dynasty of Chronos Phaenon TrumanCapote (declared) // Kevan (undeclared) // Patrick McKenzie (undeclared) // Shadowsliver (undeclared) // Smith (undeclared) // any other players (undeclared) Scam [As Written] [Admin] Every player achieved victory but TrumanCapote was first to declare it.
The First Dynasty of TrumanCapote Knightking Conventional
The Second Dynasty of Knightking Quazie Conventional or Scam [Late] Possible late reveal?
The First Dynasty of Quazie Simon Scam [As Written]
The First Dynasty of Simon Angry Grasshopper Conventional
The First Dynasty of AngryGrasshopper Rodney Conventional
The First Dynasty of Rodney Aaron + Smith + ? Pooling [Bloc Vote] One player proposed to give another the choice of winning the dynasty or continuing it with the proposer as co-Emperor. They chose the former.
The First Dynasty of Aaron Josh Scam
The Second Dynasty of Josh None Other [Meta]
The Second Metadynasty Chronos Phaenon Conventional
The Second Dynasty of Chronos Phaenon Angry Grasshopper Other [Election]
The First Dynasty of Excalabur Excalabur Conventional
The Second Dynasty of Excalabur Seventy-Fifth Trombone Conventional or Scam
The First Dynasty of 75th Trombone Elias IX Other [Merit Random]
The First Dynasty of Elias IX None Other [Meta]
The Third Metadynasty Angry Grasshopper Conventional
The Second Dynasty of Angry Grasshopper Hix Conventional
The First Dynasty of Hix Thelonious Conventional
The First Dynasty of Thelonious Hix Other [Pure Random]
The Second Dynasty of Elias IX Rodney Scam + Pooling? [As Written]
The Second Dynasty of Rodney Clucky Conventional
The First Dynasty of Clucky Doremi Scam
The First Dynasty of Doremi Chronos Phaenon Other [Election]
The Third Dynasty of Chronos Phaenon Hix Conventional
The First Dynasty of Amnistar Clucky Scam [As Written]
The Second Dynasty of Clucky Amnistar + Axeling Pooling + Scam [As Written] Two players teamed up; the second player had "an idea e'd like to try" and was passed the mantle
The Second Dynasty of Amnistar Bucky Scam [As Written]
The First Dynasty of Bucky Clucky Scam [As Written]
The Third Dynasty of Clucky Josh Other [Random]
The Third Dynasty of Josh Kevan Conventional
The Fifth Dynasty of Kevan Hix Conventional
The Second Dynasty of Hix Clucky Conventional [Merit Random] Ended with a proposal for a one off dice-battle system based on acquired gamestate.
The First Dynasty of spikebrennan Jack Conventional
The First Dynasty of Jack Purplebeard Scam [As Written]
The First Dynasty of Purplebeard Rodlen Other [Election]
The First Dynasty of Rodlen Yoda Scam [As Written]
The First Dynasty of Yoda Amnistar Other [Election]
The Third Dynasty of Amnistar Darknight Pooling [Election] A proposal awarded victory early to a player with an almost insurmountable lead due to Endorsement pooling.
The First Dynasty of Darknight Bucky Conventional
The Second Dynasty of Bucky Yoda Conventional
The Second Dynasty of Yoda None Other [Meta]
The Fourth Metadynasty Arthexis + Yoda Pooling
The First Dynasty of arthexis Amnistar Conventional [Assisted]
The Fourth Dynasty of Amnistar Devenger Other [Election]
The First Dynasty of Devenger Ais523 + Influenza + Qwazukee + Klisz Pooling [Altered Bloc Vote] Votes were pooled (votes could be "bought" due to a dynastic mechanic)
The First Dynasty of ais523 Clucky + Ienpw III + Klisz Pooling [Action]
The First Dynasty of Ienpw III Qwazukee Other [Election]
The First Dynasty of Qwazukee Klisz Other [Election]
The First Dynasty of Klisz None Other [Meta]
The Fifth Metadynasty Bucky Conventional
The Third Dynasty of Bucky ais523 + Wakukee + Klisz Scam + Pooling [As Written] Collaborative scam to cast a "target player achieves victory" spell
The First Dynasty of Wakukee Kevan Scam
The Sixth Dynasty of Kevan ais523 + Flurie + Hellzapoppin + Klisz Pooling [Action] To win, you needed to guess some information (and could only try once); the pool pooled their information, then used their numbers to make multiple guesses.
The Second Dynasty of ais523 Josh + Klisz Scam + Pooling [As Written] [Resource] Dynasty factor pooled. Collaborative scam.
The Fourth Dynasty of Josh Purplebeard Scam [As Written]
The Second Dynasty of Purplebeard ais523 Scam [As Written]
The Third Dynasty of ais523 Ienpw III Conventional [Election] themed dynasty
The Second Dynasty of Ienpw III Klisz Other [Election]
The Second Dynasty of Klisz Galdyn + Ienpw III Pooling
The First Dynasty of lilomar Coppro Scam [As Written]
The First Dynasty of coppro Ais523 Scam [As Written]
The Fourth Dynasty of ais523 Kevan Scam [As Written]
The Seventh Dynasty of Kevan Brendan // Roujo Conventional // Scam Main dynasty won conventionally after an [As Written] scam led to it being restarted.
The Second Dynasty of Brendan Alecto + Josh + Kevan Scam + Pooling [As Written] With a "last zombie standing wins" rule, the game's three zombies agreed to roll a die to decide which two would voluntarily idle.
The First Dynasty of Alecto Josh Scam [As Written]
The Fifth Dynasty of Josh Clucky Conventional
The Fourth Dynasty of Clucky Purplebeard Conventional Possible minor pooling from Subrincinator and Chivalrybean
The Third Dynasty of Purplebeard Kevan Scam [As Written]
The Eighth Dynasty of Kevan Ais523 + Florw + Lilomar Scam + Pooling [As Written] [Admin] [Resource] Read-as-written. Admins used their Admin powers defensively to protect an overly lenient victory method. Players pooled their actions to reach the winning combination.
The Fifth Dynasty of ais523 Purplebeard Scam [As Written]
The Fourth Dynasty of Purplebeard Galtori + Travis + Yoda Scam + Pooling [As Written] [Resource]
The Third Dynasty of Yoda Bucky Other [Election]
The Fourth Dynasty of Bucky Kevan Conventional
The Ninth Dynasty of Kevan Bateleur Conventional
The First Dynasty of Bateleur None Other [Meta]
The Sixth Metadynasty Ais523 + Coppro + Comex Pooling [Resource]
The Second Dynasty of coppro Ais523 Conventional
The Sixth Dynasty of ais523 Clucky + Cpt_Koen + Omd + Southpointingchariot Pooling [Resource]
The First Dynasty of Cpt_Koen Clucky Other [Merit Random]
The First Dynasty of southpointingchariot Josh Conventional
The Sixth Dynasty of Josh scshunt Scam [As Written]
The Third Machine of scshunt Quirck Conventional + Pooling One of two tied leading players proposed to let the other win.
The First Dynasty of Quirck Clucky Conventional
The Fifth Dynasty of Clucky Bucky + Quirck Pooling Bucky "bribed" Quirck (it is unclear with what) to idle out and trigger their own victory
The Fifth Dynasty of Bucky Kevan Conventional
The Tenth Dynasty of Kevan Scshunt Conventional
The Seventh Dynasty of Josh Kevan Conventional
The Eleventh Dynasty of Kevan Scshunt Conventional
The Fourth Dynasty of scshunt Henri + Klisz + RaichuKFM + Larrytheturtle Pooling + Scam [As Written] [Altered Bloc Vote]
The First Dynasty of RaichuKFM Larrytheturtle Scam [As Written]
The First Dynasty of Larrytheturtle RaichuKFM Conventional
The First Dynasty of Skju None Other [Meta] Metadynasty started by proposal.
The Seventh Metadynasty Purplebeard Scam
The Fifth Dynasty of Purplebeard Spitemaster Other [Merit Random]
The First Dynasty of Spitemaster Josh Scam [As Written]
The Eighth Dynasty of Josh Clucky + RaichuKFM Scam + Pooling [As Written] [Altered Bloc Vote] Two players created a scammed UN resolution which would flip a coin and assign one of them victory
The Second Dynasty of RaichuKFM The Alien Other An NPC achieved victory
The First Dynasty of The Alien Benzene + Kevan Pooling Kevan proposed a new chamber which would assign victory at weighted random to its inhabitants, which were limited to Kevan and (it seems?) Benzene
The First Dynasty of Benzene IceFromHell + RaichuKFM Pooling A stalemate was resolved with a proposal to toss a coin for victory
The Third Dynasty of RaichuKFM Purplebeard Conventional
The Sixth Dynasty of Purplebeard Kevan Conventional + Other [Election] Players agreed to end the dynasty early, with one player in a clear lead.
The Twelfth Dynasty of Kevan Ayesdeeef Conventional
The First Dynasty of Ayesdeeef Bucky + Sprucial Pooling
The Sixth Dynasty of Bucky Kevan Conventional
The Thirteenth Dynasty of Kevan Josh Conventional
The Ninth Dynasty of Josh Brendan + Kevan + Mideg Pooling [Action] [Resource] [Mantle Roll] Actions and "Standing" were pooled
The First Dynasty of Mideg Kevan Conventional + Other [Merit Random] A sudden death die roll was proposed based on scores so far.
The Fourteenth Dynasty of Kevan Brendan Conventional
The Third Dynasty of Brendan Kevan Conventional
The Fifteenth Dynasty of Kevan Tantusar Conventional
The First Dynasty of Tantusar Josh Scam [As Written]
The Tenth Dynasty of Josh Kevan Scam [As Written] [Admin] Read-as-written. Scam discovered by a non-Admin but performed by an Admin.
The Sixteenth Dynasty of Kevan Ais523 + Thrawn Conventional + Pooling Midgame agreement to pass the mantle if assisted
The First Dynasty of Thrawn Brendan Conventional
The Fourth Dynasty of Brendan Kevan Conventional
The Seventeenth Dynasty of Kevan Quirck (declared) // Kevan (undeclared) Conventional The ruleset was such that the Emperor could nominate another player to win, if they achieved victory.
The First Dynasty of Moonroof RaichuKFM Conventional + Scam Dynastic voting mechanics enabled an unstoppable scam proposal.
The Fourth Dynasty of RaichuKFM Larrytheturtle Conventional
The Second Dynasty of Larrytheturtle Brendan (declared) + Kevan (undeclared) Pooling + Scam Collaborative scam to earn Kevan a "win the game" item, where after a coin flip he declined to declare victory and passed it to Brendan
The Fifth Dynasty of Brendan Kevan Scam
The Eighteenth Dynasty of Kevan Brendan Scam
The Sixth Dynasty of Brendan RaichuKFM Other [Merit Random] The front-runners were forced into a coinflip (seemingly against one of their wishes) after endgame looked to be down to the timing of a future Imperial action.
The Fifth Dynasty of RaichuKFM Kevan Conventional
The Nineteenth Dynasty of Kevan Brendan Conventional
The Seventh Dynasty of Brendan Kevan Conventional
The Twentieth Dynasty of Kevan Viv Conventional
The First Dynasty of Viv pokes Conventional [Assisted]
The First Dynasty of pokes Sphinx Conventional
The First Dynasty of Sphinx Cuddlebeam + Pokes Pooling [Resource] Players flipped a coin to decide who to pool game-winning Artefacts to
The First Dynasty of Cuddlebeam pokes Scam [Admin] Infinite combo to achieve enough of victory currency performed shortly after admin enactment.
The Second Dynasty of Pokes Card + Cuddlebeam + Derrick + Sesquipedalian Pooling [Altered Bloc Vote] Pooling team pushed through a "random team member wins" proposal (voting power differed between players due to a dynastic mechanic)
The Second Dynasty of Cuddlebeam None Other [Meta]
The Eighth Metadynasty Axemabaro Conventional + Scam ?
The First Dynasty of Axemabaro Diabecko Conventional / Scam Gradual gaining of advantage via smaller clever plays/scams
The First Dynasty of Diabecko Kevan Conventional
The Twenty-First Dynasty of Kevan Card + Diabecko Pooling [Resource] Dynastic Factor was pooled (Coins)
The First Coregency of Diabecko and card Kevan Other [Election]
The Twenty-Second Dynasty of Kevan Derrick (declared) // Cuddlebeam (undeclared) Conventional // Scam -//[Late] Late reveal
The First Dynasty of Derrick card Conventional [Assisted]
The First Dynasty of card Cuddlebeam + Derrick + Kevan + Pokes + 9SpaceKing Pooling [Bloc Vote] A CfJ was raised to assign victory to a random early supporter of that CfJ
The Third Dynasty of Cuddlebeam card Other [Pure Random]
The Second Dynasty of card Kevan Scam [Admin] Selective adminning in the admin's favour
The Twenty-Third Dynasty of Kevan pokes Conventional
The Third Dynasty of pokes Kevan Conventional
The Twenty-Fourth Dynasty of Kevan Trigon Conventional
The First Dynasty of Trigon Derrick Conventional [Assisted]
The Second Dynasty of Derrick Kevan Conventional
The Twenty-Fifth Dynasty of Kevan Derrick Conventional
The Third Dynasty of Derrick Ienpw III + Kevan + TyGuy6 Pooling [Resource] Dynastic factor was pooled (Food). Some suggestion that mantle rolling was discussed, but not used by the team who won.
The First Dynasty of Farsight Thunder + TyGuy6 Pooling [Action] [Mantle Roll] Thunder agreed to act as an inert target for TyGuy's attacks, to help them score Treasure.
The First Dynasty of TyGuy6 Kevan + Pokes Pooling [Action] [Mantle Roll] Kevan and Pokes were virtually tied on a slow route to victory, and agreed to trigger the endgame early and mantle roll from whatever the outcome was, rather than play it out and possibly be sniped by other players.
The Fourth Dynasty of pokes Cuddlebeam + TyGuy6 Pooling [Action] [Mantle Roll] With only three active players, Cuddlebeam proposed that they win the game, with TyGuy6 supporting in exchange for a 50% mantle roll.
The Fourth Dynasty of Cuddlebeam TyGuy6 Conventional
The Second Dynasty of TyGuy6 Cuddlebeam Other [Pure Random]
The Twenty-Sixth Dynasty of Kevan Card + Cuddlebeam + Darknight + The Duke of Waltham Pooling + Scam [Action] [Resource] [As Written] [Mantle Roll] Various different maneuvers performed for the benefit of a single player's victory condition.
The First Dynasty of The Duke of Waltham Josh Scam [As Written] Read-as-written.
The Eleventh Dynasty of Josh Clucky + Naught Pooling [Action] Naught lowered their score to allow Clucky to win
The Sixth Dynasty of Clucky Naught Other [Merit Random]
The First Dynasty of naught none Other [Meta]
The Ninth Metadynasty Kevan Other [Merit Random]
The Twenty-Seventh Dynasty of Kevan Josh + Cuddlebeam Pooling [Action] [Mantle Roll] Cuddlebeam followed instructions for 40% of mantle
The Twelfth Dynasty of Josh Clucky Conventional Called early
The Seventh Dynasty of Clucky Josh Conventional
The Thirteenth Dynasty of Josh Bucky + CoderBlaze Conventional + Pooling Ruleset forced team victories to be resolved at random
The Seventh Dynasty of Bucky Brendan + Josh + Clucky (declared and enacted) // Kevan (declared) // Raven1207 (undeclared) Pooling [Bloc Vote] [Mantle Roll] A scam unintentionally gave multiple players victory; four of those players sold mantle roll offers in exchange for votes supporting their preferred DoV
The Fourteenth Dynasty of Josh Kevan Conventional
The Twenty-Eighth Dynasty of Kevan Josh + Brendan + Lemonfanta + Pokes + Jumble + Darknight Pooling [Resource] [Action] [Mantle Roll] Players pooled Pegs and resigned subgames to assist a single player. This was partly under the tracked Favours rule but also included a mantle roll.
The First Dynasty of lemonfanta Clucky + Kevan Pooling [Action] [Mantle Roll] [Traitor] An agreed mantle roll plan was declined by the Traitor.
The Eighth Dynasty of Clucky Josh Conventional [No Comms]
The Fifteenth Dynasty of Josh Jumble Other [Merit Random] Merit based on Blood Mana Crystals.
The First Dynasty of Jumble ais523 Scam [As Written] Borderline case: A series of normal moves were strung together into a over 6,000 move update, immediately achieving victory.
The Seventh Dynasty of ais523 Josh + Trapdoorspyder + Cuddlebeam Conventional + Pooling [Action] [Mantle Roll] Josh enacted a series of proposals which would work together to grant him victory, and brought some votes from Trapdoorspyder and Cuddlebeam to ensure that the queue stayed locked
The Sixteenth Dynasty of Josh Kevan + Clucky Conventional + Pooling [Resource] [Mantle Roll] [No Comms] Clucky donated some Citizens to a critical Building, but later retracted a mantle roll agreement due to some (limited ruleset-permitted backchannel) miscommunication around possible scams that didn't actually work.
The Twenty-Ninth Dynasty of Kevan Trapdoorspyder + Cuddlebeam + TyGuy6 + redtara Other + Pooling + Scam [Election][Resource] [Mantle Roll] A cabal of players achieved enough of a poolable resource that would allow them to win (partially scam-gained). This was used as merit to achieve a winning CFJ, due to unconventional circumstances concerning the Emperor.
23 October 2021: Players vote in a dynastic rule of "the mantle may not be passed" during the next dynasty; it is kept in place for the one after it, and then made into a default-off Special Case rule
The First Dynasty of Trapdoorspyder None None [Meta] [No Mantle] An enacted Merit Random resolution contained a scam that was voted down, and could not otherwise be processed. Players then voted to play a metadynasty which only two of the possible merit-random winners of this dynasty could win.
The Tenth Metadynasty Brendan Pooling [Bloc Vote] [No Mantle]: Played as a tiebreaker dynasty between two not-quite-quorate teams, a defector supported Brendan's victory proposal.
The Eighth Dynasty of Brendan Brendan + Kevan Pooling [Resource] [Mantle Roll] [No Comms] [No Mantle] [Alliances] Information was shared (the Dark One's weakness) to coin flip on one of those players winning. No Mantle and No Comms were in effect but didn't apply to the Malign Emperor.
The Ninth Dynasty of Brendan Clucky + TyGuy6 + Zack Pooling [Resource] [No Mantle] [Alliances] Players pooled freely-tradeable coins to hit the victory condition (Josh and Jumble had also donated coins to the ultimate winner, but not with the intention of a victory split).
The First Dynasty of Zack Jumble Other [Merit Random] An unexpected interaction of several rules allowed anyone to claim free winshare for the end-of-game roll-off.
The Second Dynasty of Jumble Brendan + Josh + ? Scam [As Written] [Mantle Roll] Brendan won via exploiting a mechanic that allowed him to take any action, then passed it to Josh in an undisclosed victory split.
The Seventeenth Dynasty of Josh MadisonSilver Scam [As Written] [No Mantle] [Alliances] Some kind of manipulation of the GPT text generator that the dynasty was using.
The First Dynasty of MadisonSilver Josh Other A DoV which turned out not to be based on successfully Achieving Victory was enacted anyway.
The Eighteenth Dynasty of Josh Kevan Other [Election] [No Mantle] After the ruleset was suspended due to a lack of activity, a theme-election mechanic was proposed; Kevan won as the only participant
The Thirtieth Dynasty of Kevan Lendunistus + Josh + SupernovaStarbright Scam + Pooling [As Written] [Mantle Roll] The group supported each others' changes to allow a scam to be completed
The First Dynasty of lendunistus Josh + Kevan + Trapdoorspyder Scam + Pooling [As Written] [Mantle Roll] Josh proposed a scam, two other players spotted it (?) but accepted a share of mantle roll in exchange for keeping quiet about it.
The Nineteenth Dynasty of Josh SingularByte Conventional [No Mantle]
1 September 2022: Mantle passing is now off by default
The First Dynasty of SingularByte Trapdoorspyder Other [Merit Random]
The Second Dynasty of Trapdoorspyder Bucky Scam [As Written]
The Eighth Dynasty of Bucky JonathanDark Conventional
The First Dynasty of JonathanDark Trapdoorspyder Pooling [Action] SingularByte voluntarily agreed to assist and kingmake Trapdoorspyder using the power of Katastrophe, not wanting to be Emperor themselves
The Third Dynasty of Trapdoorspyder Chiiika + Habanero Pooling [Resource] [Mantle Roll] [Alliances] Players pooled farmable Resources and combined the outputs of resource-producing Buildings to allow Chiiika to build the 4 Buildings necessary to win. Chiiika passed the Mantle to Habanero under the Alliances rule
The First Dynasty of Habanero JonathanDark Scam [Merit Random] Brendan successfully exploited an infinite resource scam; however, since there was no victory condition in the ruleset, an endgame rolloff was proposed. JonathanDark won the roll.
The Second Dynasty of JonathanDark Misty Conventional [No Comms]
The Third Dynasty of Misty none Other [Meta]
The Eleventh Metadynasty Josh Other [Merit Random] When a game action caused the outcome of the Merit Random roll to become ambiguous (either Josh or Redtara had won it and consensus was split), Redtara stood down and proposed that Josh had won it.
The Twentieth Dynasty of Josh Lemon Conventional [No Comms]
The Second Dynasty of lemon Kevan + lendunistus Pooling [Action] [Mantle Roll] [No Comms] [Alliances] Kevan performed some game actions for a 35% split of the mantle, under the Alliances rule.
The Thirty-First Dynasty of Kevan Josh Conventional [Merit Random] With a clear conventional lead, Josh proposed that the dynasty should end immediately with him 100% winning.
The Twenty-First Dynasty of Josh Clucky Conventional
The Ninth Dynasty of Clucky Vovix + Snisbo Pooling [Action] Snisbo agreed to cast a spell that would give victory to Vovix (with no chance of mantle pass) "in exchange for a general IOU"
The First Dynasty of Vovix JonathanDark + Josh + Clucky Pooling [Action] Clucky (being in with a chance of victory) and Josh (repaying a favour from an earlier dynasty) helped to kill the King.
The Third Dynasty of JonathanDark Zack Conventional
The Second Dynasty of Zack JonathanDark Other [Merit Random]